CALL NOW 888-901-1338

Collector and Classic Car Insurance for Less

CALL NOW 888-901-1338

Collector and Classic Car Insurance for Less

Top 5 Most Reliable Classic Cars

Get a Quote

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Collecting classic cars is a rich pastime that numerous motor enthusiasts enjoy. These iconic and historic rides offer unforgettable styles and specifications that preserve the fine craftsmanship of their eras. There’s truly nothing like driving one of these beauties on the open road and showcasing them at car shows. Plus, collecting classic cars is often a great investment opportunity, as these vehicles frequently appreciate over time.  If you’re just getting started with collecting cars or are looking to expand your collection, it’s important to find automobiles that will stand the test of time. Here are five of the most reliable classic cars on the market. 

1965 Ford Mustang

Although there’s much to love about contemporary Mustangs, they pale in comparison to the original. Ford released their first-generation Mustangs on April 17, 1964, technically making the first units 1964 ½ Mustangs, but they received 1965 U.S. standard VINs. 

The Mustang was an instant hit upon its release, capturing the hearts of car enthusiasts with its sleek and aggressive appearance, relatively affordable price, and powerful engine options. 

One of the key factors behind the success of the 1965 Ford Mustang was its unique combination of sportiness and practicality which is why it makes our most reliable classic cars list. It featured a long hood, a short rear deck, and three striking 2-door body styles that exuded a sense of speed and excitement: the hardtop, fastback, and convertible.

This stunning vehicle came with exceptional engine options, such as the 170 cu in Thriftpower I6, 260 cu in small block V8, and the remarkable 289 cu in small block HiPo V8. 

Its solid construction, durable components, and straightforward mechanical design make it an excellent and reliable classic perfect for pony and muscle car collectors.

plugs page break

1976 Mercedes-Benz W116 Sedan

The Mercedes-Benz W116 is a significant milestone in the German automotive manufacturer’s rich history, and the 1976 Mercedes sedan model is especially impressive. 

First introduced in 1972, the W116 was the first Mercedes-Benz to carry the “S-Class” designation, representing luxury and innovation. It boasted a sleek and elegant design that included rectangular headlights, a large chrome grille, and smooth body lines. Plus, the car features a passenger compartment reinforced with a rigid safety cell, providing robust protection in the event of a collision.

The 1976 W116 Sedan offered a range of powerful and efficient engines under its hood, including the 2.8 L M110 I6, 6.9 L M100 V8, 3.0 L OM617 turbo diesel I5, and more.

With its incredible style, performance, and safety, it’s no surprise that the W116 received overwhelming praise and accommodations. It even won European Car of the Year in 1974. The 1976 sedan version of the W116 is a highly dependable car that’s especially ideal for a European luxury car collection. 

red plugs

1984 Jeep Cherokee XJ

The 1984 Jeep Cherokee holds a significant place in the history of sport utility vehicles, known as Sportwagons at the time, and is a reliable classic. The vehicle was the first Jeep to feature a ladder-boxed chassis with a single monocoque unit. This new construction was much lighter weight, greatly enhancing the vehicle’s performance. 

The vehicle received much praise for its off-road capabilities and came with 2-door and 4-door options. Additionally, motorists could obtain a Jeep with either rear-wheel or four-wheel drive. 

The 1984 Jeep Cherokee boasted a 150 cu in AMC I4 or a 173 cu in GM LR2 V6, and Jeep went on to offer more gas and diesel engine options in later models. 

The SUV’s combination of ruggedness, versatility, and capable performance made it a popular choice among off-road enthusiasts and everyday drivers alike. It remains an impressive classic today. 

plugs page break

1984 BMW 3 Series E30

BMW debuted its first generation 3 Series in 1975 with the E21. The E30, the car’s second generation, debuted in 1982. The initial E21 generation laid the foundation for the second generation’s success with its stylish design and agile handling. 

The E30 refined and improved upon its predecessor with a more aerodynamic design with sleek lines, improved fuel efficiency, and enhanced handling characteristics. The car boasted a rear-wheel-drive setup and a well-tuned suspension system that used front MacPherson struts and a rear semi-trailing arm, offering precise steering and exceptional cornering capabilities. 

The 1984 BMW 3 Series was one of the first BMW models to feature an onboard computer, providing the driver with valuable information and system diagnostics. Its powertrain options included a 1.8 L M10 straight-4, a 2.0 L M20 straight-6, and a diesel 2.4 L M21 straight-6 turbo. 

The dependable BMW 3 Series E30 remains a highly celebrated automobile among classic car enthusiasts. 

red plugs

1991 Toyota Land Cruiser

Finally, on our most reliable classic cars list, we have the 1991 Toyota Land Cruiser, a rugged and versatile SUV known for its exceptional durability and off-road capabilities. 

Toyota’s Land Cruiser dates back to 1951 with the Toyota “Jeep” BJ prototype. The Japanese automaker continued refining its original vision through the decades and released a truly remarkable version with the 1991 Land Cruiser 80 series. 

It boasted an advanced four-wheel-drive system, providing exceptional traction that made it perfect for muddy and rocky terrains. Plus, the vehicle boasted an open center differential and anti-lock brakes. 

What was especially notable about the 80 series was its new line of diesel options, which included a 4.2 L 1HZ I6, a 4.2 L 1HD-T turbocharged I6, and a 4.2 L 1HD-FT turbocharged I6. Plus, Toyota offered a gasoline 4.0 L 4.0 L 3F-E I6 and 4.5 L 1FZ-FE I6. 

The 1991 Toyota Land Cruiser’s robust construction, powerful engine options, and off-road prowess make it a highly dependable classic, and the iconic vehicle is especially desirable for those prioritizing utility.

plugs page break

Get Dependable Classic Car Insurance for Your Ride 

Whether you invest in one of the most reliable classic cars on our list or another fine classic, you need to protect your cherished ride with classic car insurance. 

For flexible plans based on agreed-upon value, contact Classic Auto Insurance. We pride ourselves on supplying classic car collectors and hobbyists with the best antique car insurance around, and we can help you get the utmost protection for your prized piece of motor history.

Call us today at 888-901-1338, or you can get an instant quote online here

Scroll to Top

Join Our Car Community

We are automobile lovers just like you. Join our monthly e-newsletter, we will keep you up-to-date on car restoration, maintenance & repair, and share with you some automotive history.